Die Fantastischen Vier have made quite a few live recordings. And they are a great live hiphop crew. More experienced live than most crews too. Heimspiel (4 LP) document their 20-year anniversary concert, Long Player on Tour (4 LP), their latest, their 35 years as a group. And counting!
Both concerts were recorded in Fanta hometown Stuttgart, so they gave all they had live on both occasions. Stuttgart is a hiphop metropolis, but I bought both albums on LP in German’s undisputed hiphop capital Hamburg in December, had them both on CD from before.
Can they be compared? 10 same songs are on both albums, 25 years apart. Heimspiel is by a much younger band, but still a very experienced band, after 20 years together. It is a very fine live album, Neues Land in a superb version and the last side H is among the best they have ever recorded, a wonderful version of Tag am Meer before an explosive adrenalin-filled and stunning Ernten Was Wir Säen, before ending with Populär. Yes, Fanta4 sure were and are Populär in Germany. There are some duller moments on the album where the material is slightly weaker, but this is compensated by the fantastic highlights. A great album.
The soundscape is somewhat different on Long Player, were electro-influences are much stronger. If Heimspiel was a much more analogue album with impressive strings and brass musicians on stage, Long Player makes use of synthesized electro-sounds and produce a soundscape that is clearer and crisper. There are pros and cons for both when comparing. Comparing setlists, I would on a whole consider Long Player the stronger material, but there is of course 25 more years of great music to choose from. This includes later favorites like Danke, Endzeitstimmung and Zusammen. That said, Heimspiel has also a fine setlist, and as earlier mentioned, the highlights and the energy-level is astounding.
The highlights on Long Player on Tour are also spectacular, and over 4 LP:s we find some weaker spots also here. But overall it feels like the slightly better whole. In itself spectacular that Fanta4 has kept up performances and appearances for this long, and still sound even better. Impressive!
I would not choose either one, but rather see them as complementing albums, complementing the picture of a truly fantastic band, Die Fantastischen Vier. They also documented their large 30 year anniversary as a band with a live album, but this time recorded in Köln. It’s another stunner, but I have a weak spot for the live celebrations in their hometown, especially after having lived in Stuttgart myself. If you go for only one Fanta4 live album you can easily choose any of these three and still have a great Fanta4 live album in your collection. Strings or electro? Your choice.
All considered, however, I find Long Player on Tour the stronger album, and my first choice, but I would not want to be without the magnificent highlights of Heimspiel. 30 Jahre concert is another, third, wonderful live document of the Fanta4 saga, strongly ending with a beautiful Zusammen. Yes, still together, and now over 35 years. And 30 Jahre was a recording from the last truly great live music year, before corona changed everything, 2919. There you have it.
Die Fantastischen Vier. Live. Always great on vinyl.
Your choice.